Oil painting by Pieter Brueghel the Elder, realized in 1559, entitled
“The Fight between Carnival and Lent”, now in the Kunsthistorisches
Museum, Vienna.
The new year and spring festivals which, in the course of time, have
been merged in that complex set of folk customs called Carnival, have
always been regarded with suspect and hostility by the Church, because
of their patent connection with pre-Christian beliefs. For this reason,
the Church has committed itself, perhaps even in the choice of the feast
name, to disempower and control the symbolic extension of this feast.
Indeed Carnival (in Spanish Carnestollendas) makes reference to the
period which immediately precedes the imposition of the ban on the consumption
of meat and the beginning of fasting (in German Fastnacht), established
by Lent. This period was thus seen as a sort of introduction (Spanish
Antruejo, from Latin introitus, “entrance, entry”)
to Lent. Folk culture has established thus a symbolic contrast between
the period of revelry, of the “fat” food, of exuberance
and licence (Carnival) and the period of penitence, of fasting, of submission
to rigid moral rules (Lent).
The period of Lent, however, maintains also the character of a preparation
for the spring festival of Easter, and of a purification phase, resuming
the idea, developed in the Roman world, of the month of February as
a period devoted to purifications, understood as a regeneration of nature
(Latin februo, “to purify”). Lent corresponds also
to a critical period in the cycle of agricultural production: the cold
season is not still over and spring is not still begun. “If it
is true that “one cannot” eat fat food, it is also true
that however – since the winter supplies were exhausted –
this could not be done in any case. The dry, light diet, assumed with
spirit of penitence thinking to the forty days spent by Jesus in the
desert, has in reality also its functional good reason” (Cardini
1995, p. 167).
The Carnival festivals have inherited in part the tradition of the Feast
of the Fools or of the Innocents, executed by the young clerics and
students, during the initial period of the year, the Twelve Days between
Christmas and Epiphany, as well as the feasts of the associations which
acted out mocking plays, forms of reversal of social roles and of satire
of authorities and hierarchies. But they resume also much more ancient
customs, ceremonies for the renewal of the seasons, of propitiation
of fertility for the fields and of the forces of nature (Heers 1983,
p. 223). Carnival masquerades represented, in continuity with pre-Christian
religious beliefs permeating the mentality of medieval humanity, also
a personification of the dead, returning in the moment of the yearly
cycle which anticipates the resurgence of the vital and generative force
corresponding to the spring season. From the earth emerged those beings
that possessed human, animal and plant attributes, figures which are
amenable to that of the Wild Man. An indication of this connection between
life and death can be found in the typical foods of the Carnival period:
pork and the broad bean (fava bean). Behind the banquet of pork there
is a death ritual: the slaughtering of the pig as a sacrificial action
and the animal’s testament (the latter appearing in popular literature
and constituting a variant of the Carnival’s testament, who is
condemned to death). The broad bean, in its turn, is a vegetable which
belonged to the realm of the dead (according to the representation of
it that was diffused by ancient Pythagoreans). The two foods together
are remained as the traditional dish of the New Year evening, the “zampone”
(“pig’s foot”) with lentils, which continues to be
regarded as auspicious for the next year’s prosperity (Cardini
1995, p. 191-192).
[Image: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Der_Kampf_zwischen_Karneval
_und_Fasten_%281559%29.jpg]